Ordinary Men Afterword: The Goldhagen Debate
What if two scholars look at the exact same evidence and reach opposite conclusions? Not different sources. Not different time periods. The same court records, from the same police battalion, about the same massacres. That is what happened when Daniel Jonah Goldhagen published Hitler’s Willing Executioners in 1996 – four years after Browning’s Ordinary Men – and used the Reserve Police Battalion 101 testimony to argue something fundamentally different.